Pearl Abyss just dropped their most ambitious title yet with Crimson Desert. Months and honestly, years, of hype built this game up into something that felt like it needed to redefine the genre. And now that it’s finally in players’ hands, the reaction has been…mixed. Some players are calling it underwhelming almost immediately. Complaints about difficult controls, inconsistent visuals, and a story that doesn’t exactly grab you right away have flooded timelines and comment sections.

But here’s the thing I keep coming back to: it feels like everyone wants to have THAT opinion first.

I get it. Being early matters online. Being a part of that first wave of takes, whether good or bad, means visibility. It means clicks. It means being in the conversation while the takes are hot. But when everyone is rushing to an early conclusion, I think a lot of people are missing out what Crimson Desert is actually trying to do. This isn’t a game that reveals itself in the first few hours. It almost actively pushes against that idea.

Slow Down. Seriously.

Crimson Desert is a game meant to be taken in slowly. Not just suggested, required. It leans heavily into systems and design philosophies that feel closer to an MMO than a traditional single-player experience. And if you try to play it like a checklist-driven, main-quest-only sprint, you’re probably going to bounce off it hard.

I’ve already spent a few hours doing things that, on paper, sound completely disconnected from “progress.” Chopping down trees. Liberating points of interest from bandits. Randomly engaging in arm wrestling mini-games. Wandering off paths just to see what’s over the next hill.

Is it weird? Yeah. Does it make sense at the start? Nope. But is it fun and rewarding? Absolutely. That’s where the game starts to click. When you stop asking “What should I be doing?” and instead start asking “What can I be doing right now?”

There’s a subtle shift that happens when you let go of urgency. Suddenly, the world doesn’t feel like filler between missions (like what happens in most open-world games) it becomes the experience.

It Doesn’t Make Sense….Yet

A big criticism early on is that the game throws a lot at you, and yeah, that’s completely fair. The opening hours are SUPER dense with tutorials, systems, mechanics, and controls that don’t always feel natural at first. It can feel like you’re learning five different games at once.

Combat alone has a learning curve. Movement has weight to it. Interactions aren’t always immediately clear (I have jumped countless times instead of picking up an item).

But once you push past that initial friction, something interesting happens: the systems start to connect. It BECOMES more natural.

Combat becomes less about button mashing and more about rhythm and positioning. Exploration becomes less about wandering aimlessly and more about intentional curiosity. Even smaller activities like gathering, rock/paper/scissors, or side encounters, start feeding into your overall progression in ways that aren’t immediately obvious at the start.

It doesn’t “click” all at once. It unfolds.

And that’s a big reason why early impressions are so divided. If you stop at hour two, you’re seeing a completely different game than someone at hour ten, twenty, or forty.

A Whole New World To Live In

If I had to compare Crimson Desert to anything, I’d say it sits somewhere between The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom and Red Dead Redemption 2.

From Tears of the Kingdom, it borrows that sense of freedom. The idea that the world is a sandbox of possibilities rather than a straight path forward. You’re encouraged to experiment (especially with your abilities), to try things just because you can, and to embrace the unexpected.

From Red Dead Redemption 2, it pulls that slower, more deliberate pacing. The world feels lived in. There’s a weight to actions, a sense that you’re existing in the environment rather than just passing through it. Heading through towns reminded of my Saint Denis visits as Arthur Morgan.

And like both of those games, it asks for patience.

Not everyone is going to want that. Some players want fast travel (which there is, sort of), objective markers, and a clear sense of forward momentum at all times. And that’s completely valid. But Crimson Desert is clearly designed for a different kind of experience, one where the journey is the content.

As Far As The Eyes Can See

One thing that genuinely surprised me is how good the game looks when you give it a moment to breathe.

There have been complaints about inconsistent visuals, and I can see where that comes from. On the standard PS5 version I am playing, visuals can blur out or feel a little less than stellar. Some areas don’t immediately impress for sure. Certain moments feel less polished than others. But when you stop rushing and actually take in the world, there are moments that genuinely stand out.

The draw distance alone is impressive. Standing on a hill and looking out across the landscape, seeing distant structures, forests, and terrain seamlessly blend together, gives a real sense of scale. I’ve definitely had those “WOW” moments while looking down at the entire map while on a floating island.

And it’s not just about fidelity, it’s about atmosphere.

Lighting shifts throughout the day. Weather changes subtly alter the mood of an area. Small environmental details, things you’d miss if you were sprinting from objective to objective, start to stand out.

Again, it all ties back to pacing. The game rewards you for slowing down.

Not For You, For Me.

It’s perfectly fine if Crimson Desert isn’t your type of game. That’s probably the most important thing to acknowledge.

There are players who bought into the hype, expecting a fast-paced, instantly engaging action experience, and that’s not what this is. And when expectations don’t match reality, disappointment is inevitable.

On the flip side, there are also players who go in wanting to dislike it. Whether it’s skepticism toward the hype, frustration with previous titles, or just the general online culture of contrarian takes. It happens. Both sides exist.

And both are loud.

But somewhere in the middle is the actual experience of playing the game on its own terms.

How Should You Feel?

Is this a 10/10 game that lived up to all the hype? No. Not even close. It has rough edges. The onboarding is messy. The story doesn’t immediately hook you. And the controls can feel like a barrier before they feel like a tool.

But is there something here? For sure! There’s a depth to Crimson Desert that doesn’t show itself right away. A sense of discovery that only really comes through time and patience. A world that feels more rewarding the less you try to force your way through it.

If you bought the game and walked away after two or three hours feeling disappointed, I get it. I really do. But I’d also challenge you to try approaching it differently. Slow it down. Ignore the pressure to “progress.” Pick a direction and just go. Chop down a tree. Fight a random group of enemies. Try something that feels pointless. Let the game be weird for a bit.

Because that’s where it starts to shine.

At the end of the day, Crimson Desert isn’t trying to win you over immediately. It’s not chasing that instant gratification that so many modern games rely on. Instead, it’s asking for your time. And if you’re willing to give it that, you might find yourself enjoying it a lot more than you expected.

Looking for more Don’t Revive Your Friends? Check out some articles below: